When I first started looking for fixers in 1980, Bungalow Heaven had not been named. It was an interesting neighborhood for a “cheap house” as you could find one in need of repair for $100,000 or less, but with interest rates in the high teens and not much cash in my pocket it was still a challenge. There was a particular 2 story cape cod bungalow on Chester Street that I nicknamed the “heartbreaker” because at $120,00 it was just out of my reach. I still sigh when I drive by it today.
Fast forward to 2009 and a lot has happened in Bungalow Heaven. In 1980 many of the houses had been badly “updated” with louvered windows and what not, but now the majority of houses have been tastefully and lovingly restored. There still exists the holdout with stucco over what was once shingles or a dead lawn but that has become the exception. The restored homes and gardens are a delight and the neighborhood has a lovely feel with sidewalks and large ancient oaks. Once again I was tempted by Bungalow Heaven…
Two years ago a spiffy restored craftsman in this neighborhood went for an average of $550 a square foot. 1290 N Wilson, a 2 bdr/2bth fully redone craftsman, went for $744,000 or $568 a foot on 9/6/07.
840 Michigan, 4bdr/2bth on an oversized lot sold immediately in June 2007 for
$699,000. Well maintained but tired, this architectural beauty received the fix up treatment including a new kitchen, paint inside and out and a lovely deck off the dining room. When it was re-listed a year later for $799,450 it took 3 price reductions and three months to finally sell for $764,400 or $433 a foot. Clearly we were emerging on the other side of the market peak in bungalow heaven.
798 N Mar Vista a 2 bdr/2bth craftsman, listed for $599, 000 in 1995 was actually bid up to $725,000, a whopping $708 a foot. When it was listed a little over 3 years later on 11/12/08 for $749,000 it finally sold nine months later for $650,000 or $484 a sq foot. $708 a foot was crazy but June 2005 was a different time. $484 a square foot in today’s market still does not feel cheap!
In my hunt, I became somewhat enamored with 931 N Michigan, a total fixer listed at $574,500. Still,even at $399 a foot, it didn’t feel like a great deal when you considered it needed a minimum $20,000 exterior paint job, had only 1 bath and shared a driveway. I was aching to restore it, but my head told me no. Its neighbor 921 N Michigan not in need of quite as much fixing, sold for $600,000 or $461 a foot.
I think the real deals in bungalow heaven are the non craftsmen. The craftsmen are truly special and well, lets face it, the darlings of bungalow heaven. I bid on 1046 N Chester, a nicely detailed traditional listed for $515,000 but when the counter came back with the laundry list of items that were broken and would not be fixed, including a pool faulty from the date of its digging, an illegal structure and a lifetime of personal junk that would not be cleared, I got a tired feeling in my bones. Maybe more than I bargained for and with some 12 offers on the property, I was happy to let it go to someone else! It sold for $536,000 or $395 a sq foot on 07/21/09.